Disability Discrimination: Case Dismissed, Nurse Received Worker’s Comp Settlement.

Legal Eagle Eye Newsletter for the Nursing Profession

March 2017

  For her worker’s compensation case the nurse claimed that she could not return to her former employment as a floor nurse providing direct patient care in the hospital.

  When she later sued the same hospital for disability discrimination for refusing to rehire her as a floor nurse the nurse failed to ex-plain the inconsistency between her statements in her worker’s compensation case and her disability discrimination case.  The nurse had to convince the court that she truly believed in good faith that she was disabled to the point she could no longer work as a floor nurse when she accepted her worker’s compensation settlement, but now knows in truth that she is able to work. That is a very difficult burden of proof to meet.

  A person who claimed to be disabled to qualify for certain benefits must live with that fact, and cannot later claim to be a qualified individual with a disability who can perform the essential functions of a job he or she claimed before to be unable to do. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT TENNESSEE February 7, 2017

    A nurse was injured twice while working for the hospital, once while moving a patient and a second time when a chair slipped out from under her.  More than seven years after the first incident and eighteen months after the second she took leave from her nursing position to have surgery on her neck.  

    She was terminated after she stayed out longer than her available Family and Medical Leave Act leave and the additional personal leave the hospital allowed.  When she wanted to go back to work she applied for two nursing positions at the hospital for which she had the necessary background and experience.  However, a note from her physician’s nurse indicated she was not able to meet the hospital’s physical abilities requirements for a floor nurse which were essential to the positions for which she had applied.  The nurse also told an individual in human resources that her physician did not want her to return to floor nursing.

    While her applications were pending to return to the hospital, the nurse settled her worker’s compensation case with the hospital for the second incident.  In addition to $33,000 for time loss the nurse received a lump sum of $88,000 for permanent partial disability, that is, compensation for being unable to return to the employment she had had as a hospital floor nurse at the time of her injury.  She had also received a partial disability settlement for the first incident years earlier.  When human resources learned of the second settlement the nurse’s applications for rehiring were dropped.

    The US District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee rejected the nurse’s disability discrimination case.  The Court ruled the nurse could not explain her conflicting claims.  For her worker’s comp settlement she was a disabled worker unable to work.  For her disability discrimination case she was a qualified individual able to work despite her disability. Vaughn v. Hospital, 2017 WL 499977 (E.D. Tenn., February 7, 2017).

More from nursinglaw.com

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workers-compensation-partial-disability.htm

 

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workers-compensation-nurse.pdf

 

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workcomp.htm

 

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workplace-injury-nurse.pdf

 

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workcomp2.pdf

 

http://www.nursinglaw.com/workcomp3.pdf